We use cookies to improve your browsing experience.

And dolphins make us happy. Find out more about our cookies policy here.

Bay Shore, New York Boat Rentals - 2023

24 listings
Best Island Adventure: Fire Island Excursion
Events in Bay Shore · 6 guests

Best Island Adventure: Fire Island Excursion

5.0
$144-150hour
Cruise to Fire Island and the Great South Bay in Style
Events in Bay Shore · 12 guests

Cruise to Fire Island and the Great South Bay in Style

5.0
$355-420hour
Perfect Day Boat to Cruise , Swim and just RELAX!! FUEL INCLUDED!
Powerboats in Islip · 5 guests

Perfect Day Boat to Cruise , Swim and just RELAX!! FUEL INCLUDED!

New
$150hour
Come Enjoy A Day Of Fishing Or Relaxation Onboard Baha Cruiser 25ft!
Fishing in Islip · 5 guests

Come Enjoy A Day Of Fishing Or Relaxation Onboard Baha Cruiser 25ft!

New
$150hour
Sportsman 231 HERITAGE Center Console W/WOUT CAPTAIN Rental in Babylon, New York
Powerboats in Babylon · 9 guests

Sportsman 231 HERITAGE Center Console W/WOUT CAPTAIN Rental in Babylon, New York

5.0
$110-125hour
SPECIAL EVENT? It's A Night Club On The Water! Invite up to 30 people.
Powerboats in Oakdale · 30 guests

SPECIAL EVENT? It's A Night Club On The Water! Invite up to 30 people.

New
$600hour
Tiki Boat Tour in Oakdale, New York
Events in Oakdale · 30 guests

Tiki Boat Tour in Oakdale, New York

New
$49person
Chartered 48' 459 Meridian Motor Yacht Package
Events in Patchogue · 12 guests

Chartered 48' 459 Meridian Motor Yacht Package

New
$750hour
56’ Motor Yacht Rental in Patchogue, New York
Events in Patchogue · 6 guests

56’ Motor Yacht Rental in Patchogue, New York

5.0
$475hour
Charter 41’ Searay Sport Yacht in the Great South Bay, Fire Island  for Day Trips
Powerboats in Patchogue · 6 guests

Charter 41’ Searay Sport Yacht in the Great South Bay, Fire Island for Day Trips

5.0
$450hour
''Over The Top'' Malibu 24mxz Bowrider Rental in Northport, New York
Events in Northport · 6 guests

''Over The Top'' Malibu 24mxz Bowrider Rental in Northport, New York

New
Superowner
$541hour
2021 22’ Deck Boat in Northport, Long Island Northport, New York
Powerboats in Northport · 6 guests

2021 22’ Deck Boat in Northport, Long Island Northport, New York

4.9
$185-195hour
Beautiful and Modern 35 Foot Express Cruiser
Events in Huntington · 6 guests

Beautiful and Modern 35 Foot Express Cruiser

New
$299-345hour
Sail From Northport or Huntington, NY - $215/Hour - $36 Per Person
Sailing in Huntington · 6 guests

Sail From Northport or Huntington, NY - $215/Hour - $36 Per Person

5.0
Superowner
Best of 2022
$50person
Escape Manhattan! Take the LIRR directly to this beautiful 36' Jeanneau!
Sailing in Oyster Bay · 6 guests

Escape Manhattan! Take the LIRR directly to this beautiful 36' Jeanneau!

New
$175-275hour
HURRICANE DECK BOAT 24ft for Charter in Freeport
Powerboats in Freeport · 6 guests

HURRICANE DECK BOAT 24ft for Charter in Freeport

New
$150hour
Its "Play Time", Lets go have some fun on the water. Optional Waverunner & Tubes
Powerboats in Oyster Bay · 12 guests

Its "Play Time", Lets go have some fun on the water. Optional Waverunner & Tubes

5.0
$199-275hour
''On the Run
Events in Freeport · 12 guests

''On the Run

New
Superowner
$528hour
2010 Sea Ray Sundancer 28ft Yacht Charter in Freeport
Events in Freeport · 6 guests

2010 Sea Ray Sundancer 28ft Yacht Charter in Freeport

5.0
$200hour
Fishing Charter On 32ft
Fishing in Freeport · 6 guests

Fishing Charter On 32ft

New
$110-113hour
FUN, VERSATILE, AFFORDABLE, PARTY WITH FRIENDS OR TAKE THE KIDS TUBING
Powerboats in Oceanside · 6 guests

FUN, VERSATILE, AFFORDABLE, PARTY WITH FRIENDS OR TAKE THE KIDS TUBING

5.0
$162-180hour
Private, Luxury Boat Ride Sunset Cruises Up to 6 Passengers Max Long Beach NY
Events in Barnum Island · 6 guests

Private, Luxury Boat Ride Sunset Cruises Up to 6 Passengers Max Long Beach NY

5.0
$350hour
Enjoy Fishing On 28ft Parker Pilothouse Boat In Brookhaven, New York
Powerboats in Moriches · 8 guests

Enjoy Fishing On 28ft Parker Pilothouse Boat In Brookhaven, New York

New
$107-125hour
Sport Fisherman fishing charter in Brookhaven
Moriches · 6 guests

Sport Fisherman fishing charter in Brookhaven

New
$150hour

Bay Shore Reviews

  1. SY
    Sophia
    Its "Play Time", Lets go have some fun on the water. Optional Waverunner & Tubes

    My only complaint is that we should’ve booked it for longer …. What a gem this boat was! Captain Jeff and his daughter were the best duo: thorough, safe, hospitable and fun. We were a large group of ten with a baby plus a dog and we couldn’t have had a better time. The boat was very clean and comfortable. The jetski and floats were definitely a super plus. Let’s just say I will be contacting Jeff in the future for ALL my boating adventures!! 10/10!!

  2. Carlos
    Carlos
    Sail From Northport or Huntington, NY - $215/Hour - $36 Per Person

    Mark was a fantastic host. Our group ranged in age from 35 to 76, and he made us all feel comfortable and have a great time. His boat is awesome and he knew the best spots to explore around the bay. Thanks Captain!

  3. JS
    Joy
    Its "Play Time", Lets go have some fun on the water. Optional Waverunner & Tubes

    Capt Jeff was so friendly and made our boating experience so much fun! All the water toys, beautiful scenery it was just a perfect day! thank you ,Capt. Jeff for having our friends and fam on your boat!

  4. IB
    Ishiemah
    Its "Play Time", Lets go have some fun on the water. Optional Waverunner & Tubes

    Jeff was so much fun! A great captain and host. My friends and I enjoyed the day sailing. My favorite part was the water toys!!!!

  5. VP
    Vania
    Its "Play Time", Lets go have some fun on the water. Optional Waverunner & Tubes

    Had so much fun! Jeffrey is such a cool, patient guy. He answered all of my questions. We had the best time on the boat. Will definitely book again.

  6. YG
    Yelena
    Its "Play Time", Lets go have some fun on the water. Optional Waverunner & Tubes

    If I could put 10 stars, I would. Jeff and Claire were truly amazing! Plenty of room for all and couldn’t ask for more. The best the best the best , they made our day!!!!