Cookies & Agreements

By continuing to use this website, you have read and agree to the Terms of Use and agree to the collection and use of your information by cookies and similar technologies, as set forth in our Privacy Policy.

Fire Island, New York Boat Rentals & Yacht Charters

Page 1 of 110 listings

Cruise in Style to Fire Island on the Tiara 3500 Open Yacht
Events in Bay Shore · 6 guests

Cruise in Style to Fire Island on the Tiara 3500 Open Yacht

5.0
$260+/hour
Tiki Boat Cruise to Fire Island for up to 18 people
Powerboats in Fire Island · 18 guests

Tiki Boat Cruise to Fire Island for up to 18 people

5.0
$500/hour
41’ Searay Sport Yacht in the Great South Bay, Fire Island  for Day Trips
Events in Patchogue · 6 guests

41’ Searay Sport Yacht in the Great South Bay, Fire Island for Day Trips

5.0
$450/hour
Fire Island Fishing And Sand Bar Adventure
Events in Fire Island · 6 guests

Fire Island Fishing And Sand Bar Adventure

New
$350/hour
Fishing and Clamming Trip onboard the 23ft Parker Sport Cabit Boat
Fishing in Fire Island · 6 guests

Fishing and Clamming Trip onboard the 23ft Parker Sport Cabit Boat

New
$325/hour
28’ Panga Center Console | Sunset Cruises & Fire Island Charters
Powerboats in Fire Island · 6 guests

28’ Panga Center Console | Sunset Cruises & Fire Island Charters

New
$250/hour
Fire Island's Premier Carver Luxury Yacht | 60ft Private Charter Experience
Events in Fire Island · 12 guests

Fire Island's Premier Carver Luxury Yacht | 60ft Private Charter Experience

New
$625/hour
Best Fire Island Adventure: Beautiful Boston Whaler
Powerboats in Bay Shore · 6 guests

Best Fire Island Adventure: Beautiful Boston Whaler

New
$165+/hour
Come Enjoy A Day Of Fishing Or Relaxation Onboard Reel Serenity 2 (FUEL INCLUDE)
Fishing in Islip · 5 guests

Come Enjoy A Day Of Fishing Or Relaxation Onboard Reel Serenity 2 (FUEL INCLUDE)

New
$150/hour
Cruising South Shore of Long Island in Class
Travel in Bay Shore · 12 guests

Cruising South Shore of Long Island in Class

New
$600/hour

Fire Island Reviews

  1. TM

    Ted

    Cruise in Style to Fire Island on the Tiara 3500 Open Yacht

    We had an amazing day on the Sisu with Captain Neal and his first mate Jake. The boat was perfect for an afternoon on the water for a big group of 6 adults + 5 kids. Neal and Jake could not have been better hosts. My strongest recommendation!

  2. KO

    Ken

    Cruise in Style to Fire Island on the Tiara 3500 Open Yacht

    Neal and his son Jacob were awesome. They were very flexible and were really focused on making sure the kids and adults had a good time on the boat. The boat is spacious and immaculate. Fun time !

  3. Jessica

    Jessica

    Tiki Boat Cruise to Fire Island for up to 18 people

    We booked Jeff for part of our bachelorette party, we had the best time! Jeff and Denise were amazing hosts, they were so accommodating and thoughtful! 10/10 would recommend and would book again!

  4. KB

    Katie

    41’ Searay Sport Yacht in the Great South Bay, Fire Island for Day Trips

    Capt Jim and Kathy made our girls trip so special! It was a perfect day and a perfect boat trip. They are skilled, hospitable, and just genuinely great people. Thank you so much!!!

  5. Amanda

    Amanda

    Cruise in Style to Fire Island on the Tiara 3500 Open Yacht

    Definitely recommend Neal and a day on the Sisu. Such a comfortable ride, with all the accommodations you could ever need. It was one of the best experiences.

  6. OM

    Olivia

    41’ Searay Sport Yacht in the Great South Bay, Fire Island for Day Trips

    Absolutely perfect day on the water! Everything was so professional and lovely. We really had a terrific day. Would absolutely book again!