Cookies!

We use cookies to improve your browsing experience. By continuing to browse or closing this banner, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about our cookies policy here.

All listings in Montauk

Great sailboat rentals near Montauk, New York.

Page 1 of 18 listings

42' Catalina Sailing Yacht in the Hamptons - For a perfect day on the water /)
Sailing in Sag Harbor · 6 guests

42' Catalina Sailing Yacht in the Hamptons - For a perfect day on the water /)

5.0
$312+/hour
Enjoy the Hamptons waters on wonderful and unique Classic Mahogany Trimaran
Sailing in Sag Harbor · 25 guests

Enjoy the Hamptons waters on wonderful and unique Classic Mahogany Trimaran

5.0
$750+/hour
Classic Beauty: Nautor Swan 46' Bluewater Cruiser, Sag Harbor, New York
Sailing in Sag Harbor · 6 guests

Classic Beauty: Nautor Swan 46' Bluewater Cruiser, Sag Harbor, New York

5.0
$310+/hour
Large and Luxuriously Appointed Schooner for Private Daysails, Swims and Sunsets
Sailing in Sag Harbor · 41 guests

Large and Luxuriously Appointed Schooner for Private Daysails, Swims and Sunsets

5.0
$1,100+/hour
Private Sailing Charter – Explore the Hamptons from Sag Harbor Aboard a Beneteau
Sailing in Sag Harbor · 6 guests

Private Sailing Charter – Explore the Hamptons from Sag Harbor Aboard a Beneteau

New
$230+/hour
A large and luxurious French Sailing Yacht for up to 6
Sailing in Sag Harbor · 6 guests

A large and luxurious French Sailing Yacht for up to 6

New
$750+/hour
Sail the glamorous Hamptons in a 58ft Catana luxury catamaran
Sailing in Sag Harbor · 12 guests

Sail the glamorous Hamptons in a 58ft Catana luxury catamaran

New
$1,200/hour
Sail on a classy and fast Sailing Yacht in the Hamptons, New York
Sailing in East Hampton · 6 guests

Sail on a classy and fast Sailing Yacht in the Hamptons, New York

5.0
Snoozed - Active 17 Jun 2026

Sailing Reviews in Montauk

  1. EC

    Emily

    42' Catalina Sailing Yacht in the Hamptons - For a perfect day on the water /)

    Nate and Jaime were the absolute best from start to finish! Super great communication and excellent service - loved the swimming spot and how knowledgeable Nate was about the area and other boats. Exceeded our expectations, will definitely book with Nate again!

  2. KH

    Katy

    42' Catalina Sailing Yacht in the Hamptons - For a perfect day on the water /)

    We are so happy we chose to book with Nate! The communication was clear and concise, we knew exactly where to go when our trip came! Nate and crew were beyond accommodating and the boat is so charming! This made our trip so special!

  3. Ilona

    Ilona

    42' Catalina Sailing Yacht in the Hamptons - For a perfect day on the water /)

    We had a great day out on the water with Nate! He was very flexible with starting a bit later due to the weather and had great communication overall. He and his crew are very kind and professional. The boat is great and this is a must-do while you are in the Hamptons!

  4. JL

    Jessica

    42' Catalina Sailing Yacht in the Hamptons - For a perfect day on the water /)

    Our trip with Nate was awesome. He is a great host and made our trip incredibly comfortable and fun. He took us on a great route - where we were able to swim in clear waters, and get a good view of surrounding areas. Highly recommend! Went way above our expectations!

  5. MM

    Molly

    Classic Beauty: Nautor Swan 46' Bluewater Cruiser, Sag Harbor, New York

    Captain Alan and his boat are incredible!! We brought a group of girls for a bachelorette trip and spending the day out on the water was SO much fun. Captain Alan was so communicative and helpful throughout the process and leading up to the day of our charter. He had everything we could have needed on board and was so helpful the whole trip!! His deckie was also so incredibly helpful - we could not have asked for a better time!!! He even had floats and a paddleboard to use which was awesome. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a fun day on the water!! 10/10, no notes!!

  6. Maria

    Maria

    Classic Beauty: Nautor Swan 46' Bluewater Cruiser, Sag Harbor, New York

    Everything was top notch, Alan was very considerable and did everything to make this trip as pleasant for us as possible. The vessel is amazing and the experience was outstanding. I traveled with my two children (3&5) and it worked out really well. Highly recommend!