Noyack, New York Fishing Charters - 2026

Fishing Charter Reviews in Noyack

1. RA

   Roshan

   36ft Vintage Yacht Marlinspike Charter in Sag Harbor, New York

   Absolutely recommend! We had the most perfect day out on the water with the captain. They took great care of us, making sure we were comfortable and happy throughout the trip. We were treated to incredible sightings, and their knowledge and attention made the experience even more special. Truly an awesome day!

2. CL

   Chet

   36ft Vintage Yacht Marlinspike Charter in Sag Harbor, New York

   Captain Hagen and his boat exceeded our expectations. He set up a neat little mahogany table for our food and supplied ice cold water and ice. The boat is a classic! It was a perfect picnic boat excursion. He took us to a great little cove and anchor so we could swim around while enjoyed our food. Captain Hagen also had some great trivia and pointed out landmarks in the area. Heet us have our privacy and visit with each other, which was nice.

3. SH

   Stephen

   36ft Vintage Yacht Marlinspike Charter in Sag Harbor, New York

   Captain Hagen is a marvelous human, and took us to some outstandingly beautiful locations in his elegant wooden vessel the MarlinSpike. He hoisted us an English and French flag, as my partner is French and I'm a Londoner. The boat is spacious and there are seats in the back and on the front. Best of all Captain Hagen is multi lingual so very easy to communicate with. Knowledgable about the area around Sag Harbor, and also caring about his passengers, the boat trip was the highlight of our holiday. Thank you Captain Hagen, if we are ever back this way we will take another voyage with you and your skipper, whose name I didn't catch, but both of you made our day. Thank you.

4. DK

   DAVID

   36ft Vintage Yacht Marlinspike Charter in Sag Harbor, New York

   Our family of 4 had a great time. Terrific Captain, Great boat , Beautiful surroundings , Interesting to see the view of Shelter Island from the water. The Captain shared a lot of knowledge in a very enjoyable manner. Highly recommend the trip

5. JP

   Julia

   36ft Vintage Yacht Marlinspike Charter in Sag Harbor, New York

   Captain Hagan was a wonderful host on his boat for my friends and I. We got to anchor and explore a little remote island and showed us a few famous homes along the trip. We would use him again in a heartbeat for our next trip!

6. BH

   Blake

   36ft Vintage Yacht Marlinspike Charter in Sag Harbor, New York

   Captain Haven delivered a wonderful experience! Easy departure, some great local knowledge, and an absolutely pleasant environment throughout. Our 3 year old had a great time!