The Best Boat Rentals in New Buffalo

Expect small powerboats and pontoons to average around $150–$250 per hour, with mid-size cruisers and wake/surf boats commonly $250–$400 per hour. Larger captained yachts for shoreline and sunset cruises typically run about $500–$700+ per hour. Jet skis in the area are often about $100–$150 per hour. Prices vary by season, boat size, captain fees, fuel, and trip length, but every listing clearly shows the rate and what’s included before you book.

You’ll find an easy mix for any group: pontoons for relaxed cruising, bowriders and deck boats for beach hopping and tubing, wake boats for watersports, fishing boats for nearshore angling, classic sailboats on select days, cabin cruisers for comfort, and larger yachts for celebrations and sunset charters on Lake Michigan.

Both options are available. Captained charters are the most hands-off and popular for groups and celebrations, since the licensed skipper handles navigation, docking, and safety. If you prefer to operate the boat yourself, many owners offer bareboat rentals; the operator must meet age and experience requirements and comply with Michigan boater education rules. If you’re new to Lake Michigan or planning a party, choosing a captain usually makes the day simpler and stress-free.

Common meeting points include the New Buffalo Public Marina with transient slips at 100 West Water Street and the New Buffalo Public Boat Launch next to the public beach off Marquette Drive on the Galien River. Your exact pickup spot and parking details will be confirmed in your booking messages.

Lake Michigan cruises here showcase wide sandy beaches, towering dunes, and golden-hour sunsets. To the north you can trace the shoreline toward Warren Dunes State Park’s dramatic dune faces; to the southwest, many charters cruise past the harbor entrance toward the Michigan City pierhead lighthouse. On calmer days, some trips also meander into the Galien River marsh for a peaceful, nature-forward ride with bird and wildlife sightings.

Michigan requires a boating safety certificate for operators born after June 30, 1996 when running a motorboat. For captained charters, you do not need a license because the professional captain operates the vessel. If you plan to drive, bring proof of your boater education card and a valid ID; owners may also ask about your experience before approving the booking.

Yes, families are welcome. All legal charters provide U.S. Coast Guard–approved life jackets for the group, and Michigan law requires children under 6 years old to wear a life jacket while on the open deck when the boat is underway. Let your captain know ages and approximate weights in advance so child sizes are ready when you arrive.

Most listings allow you to bring snacks, picnics, and beverages, and many boats have coolers or space for one. Passengers may drink alcohol, but the operator must remain sober under Michigan’s boating under the influence laws. For a smoother trip, choose cans over glass and pack easy, no-mess items. If you’d like ice or catering, ask in your booking messages—crews can often help with simple add-ons.

Pet policies vary by owner and boat type. Small, well-behaved dogs are often allowed on private charters, while larger breeds may be restricted on certain vessels. Always include your pet’s size and breed in the inquiry so the owner can confirm, and bring a towel, leash, and a collapsible water bowl. A cleaning fee may apply on some boats.

Captains watch marine forecasts closely and will not depart in unsafe conditions. If wind, waves, storms, or dense fog make it unsafe, most owners offer a reschedule or refund according to the listing’s cancellation policy. Because summer weather can change quickly on Lake Michigan, consider morning departures for calmer water and keep a backup time window if your schedule allows.

Yes—this harbor is set up for groups. Many captained boats are perfect for celebrations, with comfortable seating, Bluetooth sound, and easy shoreline or sunset routes. Share your headcount, date, desired vibe, and any special touches (decor, cake, photo stops) in your inquiry; the captain will suggest the right boat and timing. For weekends in July and August, send requests early to lock in your ideal slot.

Peak boating season runs roughly May through mid-September, with the warmest lake and busiest calendars from late June to early September. Major boating holidays—Memorial Day weekend, July 4th, and Labor Day—book far in advance. Locally, July 3 fireworks and the Ship & Shore festivities often draw extra visitors, and the late-July/early-August Great Lakes Grand Prix in nearby Michigan City adds regional marina and beach traffic. For the smoothest water and easier parking, choose weekdays or morning departures; for the signature glow, sunset cruises are unmatched but sell out fastest on weekends.

Top picks include a shoreline-and-sunset cruise along the dunes, a relaxed nature run into the Galien River marsh when lake chop picks up, or a day cruise toward the Michigan City lighthouse for photos before heading back for a beach swim stop. Ask your captain about the day’s wind and wave direction; they’ll tailor a route for comfort and views.