We use cookies to improve your browsing experience.

And dolphins make us happy. Find out more about our cookies policy here.

Fishers Island, New York Boat Rentals - 2023

24 listings
Able Custom 42' Chartered Sailing Experience in Stonington, CT
Sailing in Stonington · 3 guests

Able Custom 42' Chartered Sailing Experience in Stonington, CT

New
$200-$215hour
40' Sailing Catamaran for charter in Montauk
Sailing in Montauk · 8 guests

40' Sailing Catamaran for charter in Montauk

New
$300hour
22ft Catalina Daysailer Boat Rental in Montauk, New York
Sailing in Montauk · 5 guests

22ft Catalina Daysailer Boat Rental in Montauk, New York

New
$125-$145hour
36' Aquila 2023 Power Catamaran + Seabob Rental in Montauk, New York
Powerboats in Montauk · 12 guests

36' Aquila 2023 Power Catamaran + Seabob Rental in Montauk, New York

New
$1,048hour
Charter 50' Beneteau Gran Turismo from Montauk, New York
Events in Montauk · 6 guests

Charter 50' Beneteau Gran Turismo from Montauk, New York

5.0
Superowner
$1,200-$1,300hour
Pursuit DC 325 Powerboat Rental in Montauk
Powerboats in Montauk · 6 guests

Pursuit DC 325 Powerboat Rental in Montauk

New
$995hour
68' Galeon Fly 2022 Power Mega Yacht + Seabob Rental in Montauk, New York
Events in Montauk · 12 guests

68' Galeon Fly 2022 Power Mega Yacht + Seabob Rental in Montauk, New York

New
$2,798-$2,998hour
Overspray in Old Saybrook
Powerboats in Old Saybrook · 6 guests

Overspray in Old Saybrook

New
$300hour
Rent A 2020 Yahama Ar210 Boat
Travel in Old Saybrook · 10 guests

Rent A 2020 Yahama Ar210 Boat

New
$375hour
Beautiful Bow-Rider crossover
Travel in East Hampton · 6 guests

Beautiful Bow-Rider crossover

New
$1,000hour
Captained Boston Whaler Conquest
Powerboats in East Hampton · 6 guests

Captained Boston Whaler Conquest

New
$395hour
44ft Sea Ray Motor Yacht with Licensed USCG Captain in Lyme, Connecticut
Events in Connecticut · 12 guests

44ft Sea Ray Motor Yacht with Licensed USCG Captain in Lyme, Connecticut

5.0
$350hour
50' Azimut Atlantis Motor Yacht + Seabob in East Hampton, New York
Events in East Hampton · 12 guests

50' Azimut Atlantis Motor Yacht + Seabob in East Hampton, New York

New
$1,423hour
Charter the 43' Azimut Motor Yacht + Seabob in East Hampton, New York
Events in East Hampton · 12 guests

Charter the 43' Azimut Motor Yacht + Seabob in East Hampton, New York

New
$1,173hour
27' Yamaha 2021 Deck Boat in East Hampton, New York
Powerboats in East Hampton · 10 guests

27' Yamaha 2021 Deck Boat in East Hampton, New York

New
$723hour
22' Bayliner 2021 Deck Boat Rental in East Hampton, New York
Powerboats in East Hampton · 8 guests

22' Bayliner 2021 Deck Boat Rental in East Hampton, New York

New
$487-$498hour
26' Mastercraft Surf/ski 2022 Bowrider Rental in East Hampton, New York
Powerboats in East Hampton · 12 guests

26' Mastercraft Surf/ski 2022 Bowrider Rental in East Hampton, New York

New
$723hour
Charter a 30' Classic Wooden Motor Boat in East Hampton, NY
Events in East Hampton · 6 guests

Charter a 30' Classic Wooden Motor Boat in East Hampton, NY

5.0
$388-$513hour
Charter on 50ft Beneteau Sailing Yacht in Greenport, New York
Sailing in Greenport · 6 guests

Charter on 50ft Beneteau Sailing Yacht in Greenport, New York

5.0
$213-$275hour
31’ Bertram Classic with captain. Greenport NY
Events in Greenport · 6 guests

31’ Bertram Classic with captain. Greenport NY

New
$250hour
40 Foot Tiara Yacht
Powerboats in Greenport · 6 guests

40 Foot Tiara Yacht

New
$600hour
Enjoy the Hamptons by water on our Monterey 328 SS!
Powerboats in Greenport · 12 guests

Enjoy the Hamptons by water on our Monterey 328 SS!

5.0
$500hour
Hobie One 12 ft Sailboat for rent in Sag Harbor
Sailing in Sag Harbor · 3 guests

Hobie One 12 ft Sailboat for rent in Sag Harbor

New
$99hour
36' Aquila 2021 Power Catamaran + Seabob Rental in East Hampton, New York
Powerboats in East Hampton · 12 guests

36' Aquila 2021 Power Catamaran + Seabob Rental in East Hampton, New York

New
$1,048hour

Fishers Island Reviews

  1. DR
    Devon
    Charter 50' Beneteau Gran Turismo from Montauk, New York

    Unbelievable!! Thank you Sean and Sean Jr.!! We were so lucky and had a perfect weather day on May 12th. Sean was so friendly, accommodating, and knowledgeable not to mention the boat was pristine. It was a short trip and we wish we had more time but he made it so worth it. Thank you again for making it happen. We will absolutely be returning and giving you a call. Devon Richardson

  2. TT
    Tara
    44ft Sea Ray Motor Yacht with Licensed USCG Captain in Lyme, Connecticut

    I would highly recommend!! Captain Jared and Tucker made our anniversary memorable. Communication was excellent, Jared reached out and made helpful suggestions on how we could make the most out of our ride. He was very accommodating, our guests continue to comment on how much they enjoyed our trip. We will book again soon. Thanks Jared!!

  3. TD
    Teresa
    44ft Sea Ray Motor Yacht with Licensed USCG Captain in Lyme, Connecticut

    It was my beleated birthday and we were able to see the homes of a musical artist as well as an actor. The view and stopping along Hamburg Cove where we stopped and had our meal. It was relaxing and beautiful.

  4. BH
    Bailey
    Charter a 30' Classic Wooden Motor Boat in East Hampton, NY

    This is an incredible boat and Scott is a perfect captain. We had an amazing trip including a gorgeous sunset. We will definitely be back!

  5. JD
    Jessica
    Enjoy the Hamptons by water on our Monterey 328 SS!

    So much fun, loved the boat, and the captain was very nice!

  6. John
    John
    Charter a 30' Classic Wooden Motor Boat in East Hampton, NY

    Perfect experience in the Hamptons.