Cookies & Agreements
By continuing to use this website, you have read and agree to the Terms of Use and agree to the collection and use of your information by cookies and similar technologies, as set forth in our Privacy Policy.
The Best Fishing Charters in Islamorada
Browse, book, and get out onto the water with local fishing guides and boat owners.
Suggested Searches
Types of Boats Popular in Islamorada
Tours
Explore local waters with a boat rental dedicated to sightseeing and exploration
$100-$295
Fishing Boats
Boats outfitted for fishing, from small inshore angling boats to deep-sea yachts
$115-$2,325
Yachts
From mid-size to mega yachts, these luxury boats are great for groups and celebrations
$225-$320
Snorkeling
Get off the boat and into the water with offshore snorkeling trips
$145-$225
Kayaks
Who says you need a motor to have fun on the water?
$90-$180
Pontoons
Perfect for casual cruising, sandbar stops, swimming, and parties
$150-$160
Top Fishing Charter Locations Near Islamorada
Tavernier, Florida
15 boats to rent
Key Largo, Florida
19 boats to rent
Marathon, Florida
22 boats to rent
North Key Largo, Florida
15 boats to rent
Key Biscayne, Florida
10 boats to rent
Coral Gables, Florida
61 boats to rent
Miami, Florida
1074 boats to rent
Florida Keys, Florida
94 boats to rent
Miami Beach, Florida
374 boats to rent
North Bay Village, Florida
45 boats to rent
North Miami, Florida
174 boats to rent
Bay Harbor Islands, Florida
7 boats to rent
Stock Island, Florida
22 boats to rent
North Miami Beach, Florida
34 boats to rent
Key West, Florida
44 boats to rent
Sunny Isles Beach, Florida
100 boats to rent
Aventura, Florida
42 boats to rent
Hallandale Beach, Florida
19 boats to rent
Recent Reviews in Islamorada
EF
Eric
22ft Sea Fox 226 Commander
We had a fantastic experience renting a boat from Why Knot Boat Rentals in Key Largo over Thanksgiving weekend. Braxton was incredibly flexible when some minor weather challenges popped up, and he made the entire process smooth and stress-free. Before we headed out, he gave clear and helpful instructions and shared great recommendations for places to explore on the water. The boat itself was in excellent condition, exactly as described, and performed perfectly the entire day. We would absolutely recommend Why Knot Boat Rentals to anyone looking for a great day on the water in the Keys, and we’ll definitely be renting from them again on a future trip!
Tristan
22ft Sea Fox 226 Commander
Braxton Why Knott Exclusive Rentals is super awesome and a class act. Everything went great- we snorkelled the reefs he recommended at chicken and hen and saw dolphins on our ride. Smooth and flawless, highly recommended . Check out their website for all the cool spear fishing trips they do!
MICHAEL
2022 Sea Chaser 22 HFC Rental in Tavernier, Florida
We had an amazing experience renting from Braxton! He was incredibly flexible with our dates and group size, making the whole process smooth and stress-free. What really stood out was his thoughtfulness—he provided toys, snorkel gear, and fishing rods for the kids, which made the trip even more special. The boat was clean, well-maintained, and perfect for a fun day on the water. Braxton was friendly, professional, and went above and beyond to ensure we had everything we needed. Highly recommend renting from him for a hassle-free and memorable outing!
Robert
2022 Sea Chaser 22 HFC Rental in Tavernier, Florida
5-Star Boating Tour with Captain Braxton! We had an amazing time on our boat tour with Captain Braxton! From start to finish, he made the experience seamless and enjoyable. We started with snorkeling in the bay, where he took us to a cool spot with clear waters and marine life. Afterward, we cruised to a beautiful sandbar where we could relax and soak up the sun. Captain Braxton’s knowledge of the area was impressive—he knew exactly where to go for the best experience. He was also incredibly friendly, accommodating, and made sure we were comfortable the entire time. If you’re looking for an stress-free and fun boating adventure, we highly recommend booking with Captain Braxton!
Jonathan
2022 Sea Chaser 22 HFC Rental in Tavernier, Florida
Braxton was an exceptional captain! He treated our family with incredible kindness and went above and beyond to ensure we had a fantastic time. His attentive service made our experience truly memorable. We’ll definitely be back and can’t recommend him highly enough!
MI
Melissa
2022 Sea Chaser 22 HFC Rental in Tavernier, Florida
Braxton was a great captain and took us to 2 different locations for snorkeling. He had ice and water for us as well as he was prepared for unexpected sea sickness that one of us got and provided Dramamine. Great trip from all aspects! We will definitely be back!
Top Fishing Charter Locations in the United States
Tampa, Florida
422 boats to rent
Saint Petersburg, Florida
276 boats to rent
Clearwater, Florida
257 boats to rent
Los Angeles, California
367 boats to rent
Daytona Beach, Florida
64 boats to rent
Captiva, Florida
106 boats to rent
Cape Coral, Florida
102 boats to rent
Madeira Beach, Florida
155 boats to rent
Punta Gorda, Florida
101 boats to rent
Treasure Island, Florida
150 boats to rent
Miami, Florida
1074 boats to rent
San Diego, California
108 boats to rent
Fort Lauderdale, Florida
265 boats to rent
Palm Beach, Florida
157 boats to rent
Fort Myers, Florida
80 boats to rent
Dania Beach, Florida
245 boats to rent
St. Augustine, Florida
37 boats to rent
Hollywood, Florida
253 boats to rent
How To Book on Getmyboat
Browse
Find the right listing for you and your crew, with options for boat types, group size, captained or self-charter, and lots more.
Inquire & Book
Found one you like? Send a rental inquiry with your preferred trip details, and you’ll receive an offer from your captain to book.
Enjoy
Coordinate a pick-up place and time, meet your boat captain, and get out onto the water!
Real reviews from happy Getmyboaters.
4.9 out of 5! 500,000+ reviews
